Oyster Bay Seafood Cafe Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Oyster Bay Seafood Cafe, a delightful fusion of Italian, American, and seafood flavors nestled in Lawrenceville, GA. This charming eatery captures the coastal vibe, inviting patrons to enjoy a range of exquisite dishes, from fresh oysters to perfectly fried cod and mouthwatering crab cakes. The menu offers a robust selection, ensuring there is something for everyone, including numerous vegetarian options.
One standout feature is the bustling atmosphere, where guests experience a blend of casual dining and excellent service. Happy hour specials and outdoor seating enhance the experience, while the kid-friendly atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for family outings. Notably, the restaurant accommodates various needs with wheelchair accessibility and takeout options.
Patrons rave about the rich bisque and flavorful seafood baskets, making each visit an occasion to remember. At Oyster Bay, comfort food meets exceptional quality in a quaint setting.
APPETIZERS
Crab Cakes
two grilled crab cakes topped with spicy remoulade garnished with fresh mango salsa
Smoked Fish Dip
chilled, light smoked mahimahi with cream cheese, onions, celery, topped with jalapenos and served with club crackers
Crab Dip
creamy baked crab artichoke dip served with toasted ciabatta bread
Conch Fritters
fluffy conch meat deep fried and served with spicy remoulade
Caribbean Shrimp
lightly fried shrimp tossed in our zesty creamy caribbean sauce topped with mango salsa
Fried Green Tomatoes
served with our spicy remoulade
Cuban Pulled Pork Wedge Fries
juicy cuban styled pulled pork loaded with parmesan cream sauce, bacon, jalapenos, tomatoes
Calamari
lightly dusted, seasoned and fried served with marinara
UPeel Shrimp
hot or cold shrimp seasoned with old bay, served with cocktail sauce
Calamari Fritto Misto
fried calamari, jalapenos, lemons, zucchini, served with house marinara, topped with spicy remoulade
Loaded Wedge Fries
loaded with parmesan cream sauce, bacon, jalapenos, and tomatoes
Small House Salad
Add protein Chicken 8 Shrimp 9 Salmon 20
Large House Salad
Add protein Chicken 8 Shrimp 9 Salmon 20
Small Caesar Salad
Add protein Chicken 8 Shrimp 9 Salmon 20
Large Caesar Salad
Add protein Chicken 8 Shrimp 9 Salmon 20
SALADS
HOUSE SOUPS
Cup Shrimp Lobster Bisque
Bowl Shrimp Lobster Bisque
Cup Seafood Gumbo
Bowl Seafood Gumbo
Half Cuban Sandwich
Served with your choice of one side item
Half Smoked Fish Melt
Served with your choice of one side item
One Fish Taco
Served with your choice of one side item
Veggie Alfredo Pasta
with garlic bread as the side
Lighter Side
FRIED BASKETS
Flounder Basket
Served with wedge fries and coleslaw
12 Fried Shrimp Basket
Served with wedge fries and coleslaw
Full Fried Shrimp Basket
Served with wedge fries and coleslaw
Half DZ Oyster Basket
Served with wedge fries and coleslaw MKT price
DZ Oyster Basket
Served with wedge fries and coleslaw MKT price
Fish Shrimp Basket
Served with wedge fries and coleslaw
Shrimp Oysters Basket
Served with wedge fries and coleslaw
Fish Oysters Basket
Served with wedge fries and coleslaw
FishNChips Basket
Served with wedge fries and coleslaw
Fish, Shrimp, Oysters Basket
Served with wedge fries and coleslaw
Fried Redfish Basket
panko parmesan crusted Served with wedge fries and coleslaw
Super Jumbo Shrimp Basket
Served with wedge fries and coleslaw
Monster Basket
a combination of fish, scallops, shrimp, oysters two hushpuppies Served with wedge fries and coleslaw
Raw Oysters
MKT price
Steamed Oysters
MKT price
Fried Oysters
lightly dusted fried, served with cocktail or tartar sauce MKT price
Fully Loaded Oysters
baked topped with your choice of parmesan, garlic, bacon, jalapenos MKT price
Cajun Cream Oysters
baked with cajun cream topped with tomatoes and pickled onions MKT price
Rockefeller Oysters
baked topped with butter, creamed spinach, parmesan MKT price
Gulf Oysters
Tacos a la carte
2 Chicken Tender Taco
grilled or fried allwhite meat chicken tender with lettuce tomato served with ranch or bleu cheese dressing on the side Buffalo BBQ Thai Chili two tacos per order served on soft flour tortillas
2 Asian Shrimp Tacos
fried shrimp tossed in our sweet spicy asian sauce topped with mango salsa coleslaw two tacos per order served on soft flour tortillas
2 Cajun MahiMahi Tacos
grilled cajun mahimahi with pickled onion relish, tomato spicy remoulade two tacos per order served on soft flour tortillas
2 Fish Tacos
golden fried fish filets with our signature slaw two tacos per order served on soft flour tortillas
2 BLT Salmon Tacos
grilled salmon topped with bacon, lettuce, tomatoes spicy remoulade two tacos per order served on soft flour tortillas
2 Cuban Pork Tacos
cuban styled pulled pork topped with coleslaw, onion relish, bbq sauce two tacos per order served on soft flour tortillas
Stuffed Grouper
grilled filet stuffed with crab cake smothered in our shrimp lobster bisque served with one side
Stuffed Flounder
grilled filet stuffed with crab cake smothered in our shrimp lobster bisque served with one side
Seafood Platter
a combination of fish, shrimp, scallops Broiled Cajun Fried served with one side
Whiskey Shrimp
sauteed shrimp in a whiskey cream sauce with caramelized onions bacon over toasted ciabatta bread served with one side
Baked Stuffed Shrimp
jumbo shrimp stuffed with crab cakes baked topped with garlic cream sauce served with one side
Cajun Redfish
served over rice with a cajun cream sauce served with one side MKT price
Crab Cakes
Three grilled crab cakes topped with spicy remoulade and garnished with fresh mango salsa served with one side
Cedar Plank Salmon
8oz fresh salmon filet lightly seasoned and roasted on a cedar plank served with one side
Snow Crab Legs
1 lb steamed alaskan crab legs MKT Price
Signature Dishes
Chef Specials
Redfish Rockefeller
baked red fish topped with creamed spinach and drizzled with parmesan cream sauce served with garlic parsley potatoes
Grilled Chicken Florentine
grilled chicken in our parmesan cream sauce served over spinach
Crab Crusted Salmon
crab crusted 8oz fresh salmon filet served with creamed spinach
Scampi Provencal
eight jumbo shrimp with mushrooms, garlic, white wine, house marinara, sauteed together, served over rice with garlic bread
Chicken Basket
grilled or fried allwhite meat chicken tenders served with your choice of dipping sauce, wedge fries coleslaw Buffalo BBQ Thai Chili Ranch Blue Cheese
Half Rib Basket
awardwinning ribs smoked smothered in bbq sauce served with wedge fries coleslaw
Full Rib Basket
awardwinning ribs smoked smothered in bbq sauce served with wedge fries coleslaw
Half Ribs Shrimp
awardwinning ribs smoked smothered in bbq sauce served with wedge fries coleslaw
Full Ribs Shrimp
awardwinning ribs smoked smothered in bbq sauce served with wedge fries coleslaw
Half Ribs Pulled Pork
awardwinning ribs smoked smothered in bbq sauce served with wedge fries coleslaw
Full Ribs Pulled Pork
awardwinning ribs smoked smothered in bbq sauce served with wedge fries coleslaw
Mushroom Swiss Burger
sauteed mushrooms melted swiss cheese served with a smokey mayo 14 lb 12 12 lb 15 34 lb 17 1 lb 20 All burgers are served on a kaiser bun along with one side item
Oyster Bay Burger
american cheese topped with smokey mayo, lettuce, tomato pickled onion relish 14 lb 12 12 lb 15 34 lb 17 1 lb 20 All burgers are served on a kaiser bun along with one side item
Bacon Cheese Bomb Burger
topped with applewood smoked bacon with grilled onion, smokey mayo, american, swiss jack cheeses 14 lb 12 12 lb 15 34 lb 17 1 lb 20 All burgers are served on a kaiser bun along with one side item
TNT Burger
sauteed jalapenos, onions peppers topped with jack cheese spicy remoulade 14 lb 12 12 lb 15 34 lb 17 1 lb 20 All burgers are served on a kaiser bun along with one side item
Smash Burgers
Pasta
Seafood Pasta Alla Vodka
scallops, shrimp, fish, mushrooms sauteed in a creamy vodka sauce Served with garlic bread
Lobster Ravioli
ravioli stuffed with lobster in our shrimp lobster bisque Served with garlic bread
Cajun Salmon Pasta
cajun seasoned salmon served over pasta in a garlic cream sauce Served with garlic bread
Shrimp Or Chicken Pasta
your choice of sauteed shrimp or chicken with mushrooms, peppers, zucchini onions in garlic cream sauce Served with garlic bread
Rajun Cajun Pasta
spicy cajun shrimp, andouille sausage, chicken, peppers onion in a cajun cream sauce Served with garlic bread
Chicken Parmesan Pasta
panko breaded fried chicken topped with house marinara, jack cheese, parmesan cheese Served with garlic bread
Crab Ravioli
ravioli stuffed with blue crab in a cajun cream sauce topped with fresh tomatoes Served with garlic bread
Grouper Sandwich
grilled, fried, cajun, or panko fried topped with lettuce, tomato tartar served on an onion bun served with one side item
Fish Sandwich
two pieces of white fish topped with american cheese coleslaw served with a side of tartar served with one side item
Pulled Pork Reuben
smothered in sauerkraut, swiss cheese, spicy remoulade served on rye bread served with one side item
Sloppy Jo
ground beef with chopped peppers onions in a tangy sweet sauce sliced pickles on a kaiser bun Best Bang for your buck served with one side item
Bacon Shrimp PoBoy
topped with applewood bacon, jack cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion spicy remoulade served on cuban bread Oysters MKT served with one side item
Pressed Cuban Sandwich
salami, ham, roast pork, swiss cheese, mayo, mustard pickle on cuban bread served with mojo sauce served with one side item
Chicken Parmesan Sandwich
fried chicken topped with jack cheese, parmesan cheese marinara served on a kaiser bun served with one side item
Crab Cake Sandwich
topped with spicy remoulade, lettuce tomato served on an onion bun served with one side item
Smoked Fish Melt
our smoked fish dip on grilled sourdough topped with tomato swiss cheese served with one side item
Grouper Reuben Sandwich
smothered in sauerkraut, swiss cheese, and spicy remoulade served on rye bread served with one side item
Cuban Pulled Pork Sandwich
cuban styled pulled pork topped with coleslaw bbq sauce Cheese 1 served with one side item
Sandwiches
Sides
Creamed Spinach
Wedge Fries
Coleslaw
Black Beans Rice
Garlic Bread
Hush Puppies
Garlic Parsley Potatoes
Vegetable Of The Day
Half Rack Of Ribs
Five Jumbo Shrimp
Crab Cake
Crab Leg Cluster
MKT price
Add Ons
Homemade Desserts
Giant Brownie Sundae
Shareable brownie with a scoop of vanilla ice cream drizzled in chocolate sauce topped with whipped cream
Key Lime Cheesecake
Shareable
Bread Pudding
Shareable caramelized mandarin orange bread pudding topped with whipped cream
Ice Cream Sundae
one scoop of vanilla ice cream topped with whipped cream, chocolate caramel syrup